Evaluating Sources: Articles

What makes books, articles, and other sources useful and how to evaluate them.
Need Help?
Ask Us!

Why Use Articles?

 Articles appear in publications called magazines, journals, periodicals, and newspapers.

Use articles to find:

  • The most recent research on a topic
  • Coverage of very narrow (or specific) topics
  • Coverage of current events
  • Contemporary accounts of past events and research

Types of Publications

 

Periodicals, journals, magazines fall into 'categories' determined by their overall purpose.

  • Popular:
    Written for general public; authors and editors usually not experts in subject field; purpose is to provide current, societal/cultural news and discussion.
  • News Article:
    Written or produced for general public; authors are usually journalists familiar with the local area and/or the topic. The purpose is to provide very current information on "what, where, why and how"; format may be online news sites or newspapers, radio or TV.
  • Trade:
    Written for individuals in a specific career/job or with a specific interest/hobby.  Authors are generally persons working in the field/hobby or journalists with specialized knowledge.  Articles discuss current issues but are not reports of research.
  • Scholarly:
    Written for, and authored by, researchers, educators, students. Articles are reports of original research or other scholarly discussions. The publication title often may include words such as:  journal, review, or quarterly.

Evaluating Articles

Use critical thinking skills when deciding whether an article is appropriate to use.

Consider the following:

  • RELEVANCE
    • Check the Date: Is the information current or timely for your topic?
    • Read the Abstract: This usually provides a summary of the article.
    • Scan the Headings & Subheadings: These will provide an outline of the work.
    • Read the Conclusion: The last few paragraphs in a journal or magazine article often restate the main argument, important questions and major findings.

    •  
  • RELIABILITY
    • Purpose: Is the intent to inform, entertain, persuade or educate?
    • Author: Does the author have expertise on the topic?
    • Objectivity: Are various sides or points-of-view represented? 
    • Bibliography: Are the author's sources of information cited completely?

 

Criteria list taken in whole from:
Howard, Rebecca Moore. Writing Matters: A Handbook for Writing & Research. Customized for Marquette University. New York: McGraw Hill, 2010. Print.

Getting the Articles

Here's a short video showing how Find it @ MU works. (About 4 minutes long.)

Two common ways to find out if the Libraries have access to the articles you need:

1) You are searching in an article database, but it doesn't have the full-text:  

Click on  Findit@MU button in the article citation. Another window / tab opens with two possible options:

  • Links indicating Find it @MU may have located one or more sources for full text of the article. Click on the links and follow the trail to the article. 
  • Links to search MARQCAT by the journal title or its ISSN number. The journal may be available in print or electronically through a source not searchable by Find it @MU.

2) You already have a specific citation and aren't currently searching in a database:

  • Search for the journal title in MARQCAT, the library catalog;
  • Do not search the title or author of the article, MARQCAT doesn't contain article level information.

The MARQCAT record will indicate what years we have in print and/or online, providing call number locations for the print and links to the e-journal.  Once at the e-journal, navigate to the volume, issue and page that you need.

Questions:

Didn't find the article/journal using Find it @MU or MARQCAT?  Request the article through Interlibrary Loan (ILL) by clicking on the link at the bottom of the Find it @MU window or tab.  Learn more about ILL here.

Ever wonder why the full-text isn't there?  Watch this short video about the Business of Information.